So sayeth the Tenth Circuit in Green v. Haskell County Board of Commissioners on June 8, 2009, followed on July 30th by the court en banc voting 6 to 6 to deny a rehearing. Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades.
In reading the dissent to the en banc decision, you will see the frustration and angst among both local officials and the jurists as to where to draw the line.
The board of commissioners of Haskell County, Oklahoma, authorized a Ten Commandments monument, eight feet tall, in front of the county’s courthouse in Stigler. Here it is up close:
And here it is in context:
Here is the layout of the front lawn (Appendix C, page 51 of the decision):
As you may recall, the U.S. Supreme Court decided two Decalogue cases in 2005, allowing the monument in one, Van Orden v. Perry, and finding an Establishment Clause violation in the other, McCreary County v. ACLU of Kentucky. The difference appears to be that the former had been up for many years and did not have any apparent history of being placed in support of religion.
The Haskell County monument, emplaced on November 5, 2004, was up just a year before it was challenged and the there was ample evidence that many supporters wanted it there for religious purposes. It was sponsored by Michael Bush, a construction worker and part-time minister who helped raise the money for it from local churches. Two of the three county commissioners, and several ministers, attended the unveiling of the monument (along with 200 people and representatives of 17 churches) and participated in a rally afterwards.
In speaking of the monument sometime in November 2004, one county commissioner reportedly said:
“That’s what we’re trying to live by, that right there…The good Lord died for me. I can stand for him, and I’m going to…I’m a Christian and believe in this. I think it’s a benefit to the community.”
Another county commissioner said:
“God died for me and you, and I’m going to stand up for him.”
At a rally two weeks later attended by 300-400 people, one commissioner said:
“I’ll stand up in front of that monument and if you bring a bulldozer up here you’ll have to push me down with it.”
At least one photograph in the press showed all three commissioners standing next to the monument.
The commissioners failed to distinguish their personal religious beliefs from that of the Board and consequently “left the impression that a principal or primary reason for the erection and maintenance of the display was religious.”
The Alliance Defense Fund plans to petition for certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court.
“Americans shouldn’t be forced to abandon their religious heritage simply to appease someone’s political agenda,” said ADF Senior Counsel Kevin Theriot. “As some of the dissenting judges pointed out, the three-judge panel’s decision is in conflict with both the U.S. Supreme Court and other federal appellate courts. There is no difference between this Ten Commandments display and the one at the Texas state capitol that was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court nearly five years ago.”
Here is a checklist I have prepared, based on my review of the several cases, for local government lawyers to use in managing the placement of religious monuments on public property:
1. Put up several monuments at once, including totally secular ones, like the Star Wars Pledge of Allegiance:
Star Wars Pledge of Allegiance
By Miba Reywes
I pledge allegiance to George Lucas,
the master of all that is Star Wars,
and to the movies he has created,
one galaxy, in war,
OT and PT, with Jedi
and blasters for all.
In Haskell County, the minister who sponsored the display added the Mayflower Compact on the back apparently to somehow neutralize the religious content of the display. Really, he did that. The Board didn’t know about it.
2. Have the commissioners who vote to approve the monument say things like: “So what are the Ten Commandments – I never heard of ‘em.” And “Ten? I thought there were two – drink beer and party.”
3. After the vote to authorize the monument, have a couple of commissioners say something showing that they didn’t really know what they were voting on, like: “Decalogue? I thought we were building a ‘deck of logs’ in the park.” In that way you totally insulate the commissioners from any religious intent.
4. Have Larry Flynt sponsor the monument. He’s got a kind of religion, yes, but not usually associated with this type of display.
5. Have all the ministers and other religious types stay away from the unveiling.
6. On further thought, don’t have an unveiling – have it erected on some moonless night behind the densest bush you have and a few weeks later approve a new landscape plan that eliminates the bush.
7. Glue moss to the side in the shadows and prominently engrave on the bottom of any display: “Erected anonymously and without public support on November 14, 1957”.